## An Intuitive Explanation of Eliezer YudkowskyвЂ™s Intuitive

### Learning about the mind from evidence Children's

A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation. reasoning are a prerequisite for wider acceptance of Bayesian methods in expert systems and decision support systems. A study of human reasoning under uncertainty suggests two different strategies, Introduction. Decades of research have come to a relatively unanimous conclusion on the role of formal logic in human reasoning: Naive reasoners (i.e., reasoners untrained in formal logic) make many errors when asked to respond to reasoning problems in accordance with the norms of formal logic..

### Bayesian Epistemology (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Causal Reasoning Engine An Explanation-Based Approach to. The integration ofprior knowledge and new evidence in Bayesian reasoning also gives Bayesian inference a characteristic combination ofstability and flexibility-alearner will be reluctant to give up a strongly-confirmedhypothesis, but even the most entrenched idea can be rejected if, changes in the likelihood or the prior in a way that accords with our intuitive reasoning. The Bayesian framework is generative, meaning that observed data are assumed to be generated by some underlying process or mechanism responsible for creating the.

7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis. purpose in writing the 1990 textProbabilistic Reasoning in Expert Systems was to unify this research and establish a textbook and reference for the п¬Ѓeld which has come to be known as вЂBayesian networks.вЂ™ The 1990вЂ™s saw the emergence of excellent algorithms for learning Bayesian networks from data. However, by 2000 there still seemed to be no accessible source for вЂlearning Bayesian

In An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning I tried to provide visual and physical metaphors for Bayesian probability; for example, evidence is a weight, a pressure upon belief, that slides prior probabilities to posterior probabilities. Simplicity and Goodness-of-Fit in Explanation: The Case of Intuitive Curve-Fitting Samuel G. B. Johnson (samuel.johnson@yale.edu) Department of Psychology, Yale University

The psychology of Bayesian reasoning DavidR.Mandel* Socio-Cognitive Systems Section, Defence Research and Development Canada and Department of Psychology, York вЂ¦ Here you will find an attempt to offer an intuitive explanation of Bayesian reasoningвЂ”an excruciatingly gentle introduction that invokes all the human ways of grasping numbers, from natural frequencies to spatial visualization. The intent is to convey, not abstract rules for manipulating numbers, but what the numbers mean, and why the rules are what they are (and cannot possibly be anything

Yudkowsky's "Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning" and Rovner's "BayesApplet" may both be freely used by any nonprofit organization or educational institution. No royalties or per-page charges are necessary to reproduce this document as course materials, either in printed form or online. A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation. This essay is meant for a reader who has attained a firm grasp of Bayes' Theorem. An introduction to Bayes' Theorem may be found at An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning.

The most popular online tutorial on BayesвЂ™ Theorem, Eliezer YudkowskyвЂ™s вЂњAn Intuitive Explanation of BayesвЂ™ Theorem,вЂќ opens like this: Your friends and colleagues are talking about something called вЂњBayesвЂ™ TheoremвЂќ or вЂњBayesвЂ™ RuleвЂќ, or something called Bayesian reasoning. Intuitive statistics, or folk statistics, refers to the cognitive phenomenon where organisms use data to make generalizations and predictions about the world. This can be a small amount of sample data or training instances, which in turn contribute to inductive inferences about either population-level properties, future data, or both.

Examples and exercises for conditional probabilities and Bayesian reasoning Henning Christiansen Roskilde University, Computer Science Dept. c 2008 Version 18 sep 2008 1 Motivation and overview This note refers to part chapter 3 of the course textbook by M. Negnevitsky. We п¬Ѓnd the text problematic in places, and we recommend our reader to skip section 3.3 and onwards. In this note we provide In An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning I tried to provide visual and physical metaphors for Bayesian probability; for example, evidence is a weight, a pressure upon belief, that slides prior probabilities to posterior probabilities.

Intuitive statistics, or folk statistics, refers to the cognitive phenomenon where organisms use data to make generalizations and predictions about the world. This can be a small amount of sample data or training instances, which in turn contribute to inductive inferences about either population-level properties, future data, or both. 7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis.

4/01/2011В В· An Intuitive Explanation of Bayes Theorem 1-4-2011 - Download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online. The main idea of Bayesian analysis is simple and intuitive. There are some data to be explained, and we have a set of candidate explanations. Before knowing the new data, the candidate explanations have some prior credibilities of being the best explanation. Then, when given the new data, we shift credibility toward the candidate explanations that better account for the data, and we shift

Finally, Bayesian reasoning is relevant to some important philosophical claims, such as Hume's position on miracles, design arguments for god, Occam's razor, and the principle that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. 7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis.

Explanation reesT for Causal Bayesian Networks Ulf H. Nielsen 1 uln@zurich.ibm.com Jean-Philippe Pellet,2 jep@zurich.ibm.com AndrГ© Elissee 1 ael@zurich.ibm.com 10/4/2012 4 The role of data is to re-allocate credibility: В©John K.Kruschke, Oct.2012 Bayesian reasoning in data analysis is intuitive: Possibilities are parameter valuesin a

Yudkowsky's "Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning" and Rovner's "BayesApplet" may both be freely used by any nonprofit organization or educational institution. No royalties or per-page charges are necessary to reproduce this document as course materials, either in printed form or online. An Intuitive Explanation of Bayes Theorem.pdf - Download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online.

Introduction. Decades of research have come to a relatively unanimous conclusion on the role of formal logic in human reasoning: Naive reasoners (i.e., reasoners untrained in formal logic) make many errors when asked to respond to reasoning problems in accordance with the norms of formal logic. The most popular online tutorial on BayesвЂ™ Theorem, Eliezer YudkowskyвЂ™s вЂњAn Intuitive Explanation of BayesвЂ™ Theorem,вЂќ opens like this: Your friends and colleagues are talking about something called вЂњBayesвЂ™ TheoremвЂќ or вЂњBayesвЂ™ RuleвЂќ, or something called Bayesian reasoning.

### A General Practicable Deп¬Ѓnition of Perfect Bayesian

Bayes Theorem Examples An Intuitive Guide [Epub]. 7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis., Bayesian Reasoning: Criticising the вЂCriteria of AuthenticityвЂ™ and Calling for a Review of Biblical Criticism. 23 Pages . Bayesian Reasoning: Criticising the вЂCriteria of AuthenticityвЂ™ and Calling for a Review of Biblical Criticism. Uploaded by. Raphael Lataster. Files. 1 of 2. Bayesian_Reasoning.pdf. www.raphaellataster.co... Download with Google Download with Facebook or download.

Computational Models of Intuitive Physics. A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation. This essay is meant for a reader who has attained a firm grasp of Bayes' Theorem. An introduction to Bayes' Theorem may be found at An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning., inferences involved in learning and reasoning about causal systems in a Bayesian framework. Any Bayesian inference requires a space of candidate hypotheses and a prior probability distribution over that hypothesis space..

### Bayesian Reasoning Criticising the вЂCriteria of

The psychology of Bayesian reasoning apps.dtic.mil. Explanation reesT for Causal Bayesian Networks Ulf H. Nielsen 1 uln@zurich.ibm.com Jean-Philippe Pellet,2 jep@zurich.ibm.com AndrГ© Elissee 1 ael@zurich.ibm.com Socio-Cognitive Systems Section, Defence Research and Development Canada and Department of Psychology, York University, Toronto, ON, Canada Most psychological research on Bayesian reasoning since the 1970s has used a type of problem that tests a certain kind of statistical reasoning performance. The.

probabilistic reasoning. Four experiments show that when a clear mapping can be established from given Four experiments show that when a clear mapping can be established from given statistics to the parameters of an intuitive causal model, people are more likely to use the statistics What is Bayesian Reasoning? Bayesian Hypothesis: People reason as if uncertainty is measured by subjective probability. вЂў For most scholars, this is a normative claim. вЂў For some scholars, this is a descriptive claim. Bayesian theory accomplishes two things: 1. Tells us how our existing beliefs should adjust to new information. Tells us how our probabilities should change as we acquire new

A General, Practicable Deп¬Ѓnition of Perfect Bayesian Equilibrium Joel Watson February 2017 Abstract This paper develops a general deп¬Ѓnition of perfect Bayesian equilibrium (PBE) for A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation. This essay is meant for a reader who has attained a firm grasp of Bayes' Theorem. An introduction to Bayes' Theorem may be found at An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning.

to Bayes s Theorem reasoning that you can learn from looking at Bayes Theorem For example An Intuitive and Short Explanation of BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem November 6th, 2007 - ThereГўв‚¬в„ўs a lot being said about Bayes BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem on A Guide to BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem be given as an example of applications of the Bayes Theorem Download PDF Bayes Theorem Examples An Intuitive Guide - вЂ¦ Zealots insist that if more of us adopted conscious Bayesian reasoning (as opposed to the unconscious Bayesian processing our brains supposedly employ), the world would be a better place.

Intuitive Guide PDF. Bayes theorem describes the probability of an event based on other information that might be relevant. Essentially, you are estimating a probability, but then updating that estimate based on other things that you know.This book is designed to give you an intuitive understanding of how to use Bayes Theorem. It starts with the definition of what Bayes Theorem is, but the To make a new prediction, we simply evaluate the pdf using the best parameters found. Bayesian Estimation - We have some knowledge about the problem/data(prior). We also admit that there may be many values of the parameters that explain the data and so we "look for" multiple parameters, e.g, 5 lambdas and 5 gammas that do this.

Causal explanation improves judgment under uncertainty, but rarely in a Bayesian way Brett K. Hayes1 & Jeremy Ngo1 & Guy E. Hawkins2 & Ben R. Newell 1 to Bayes s Theorem reasoning that you can learn from looking at Bayes Theorem For example An Intuitive and Short Explanation of BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem November 6th, 2007 - ThereГўв‚¬в„ўs a lot being said about Bayes BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem on A Guide to BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem be given as an example of applications of the Bayes Theorem Download PDF Bayes Theorem Examples An Intuitive Guide - вЂ¦

A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation. This essay is meant for a reader who has attained a firm grasp of Bayes' Theorem. An introduction to Bayes' Theorem may be found at An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning. Yudkowsky's "Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning" and Rovner's "BayesApplet" may both be freely used by any nonprofit organization or educational institution. No royalties or per-page charges are necessary to reproduce this document as course materials, either in printed form or online.

causal understanding of a problem leads to increased adoption of Bayesian reasoning, promotes the use of non-Bayesian heuristic strategies, or leads to a mixture of such strategies across individuals. Finally, Bayesian reasoning is relevant to some important philosophical claims, such as Hume's position on miracles, design arguments for god, Occam's razor, and the principle that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

14/08/2016 · There are many programs that you could use in order to manage your files. One of them is Easy CAD to PDF Converter. It's a neat software solution that convert CAD drawings, such as DWF, DWG … Cad drawing to pdf converter Prince Edward Island 14/08/2016 · There are many programs that you could use in order to manage your files. One of them is Easy CAD to PDF Converter. It's a neat software solution that convert CAD drawings, such as DWF, DWG …

## Intuitive statistics Wikipedia

The psychology of Bayesian reasoning ResearchGate. 7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis., What is Bayesian Reasoning? Bayesian Hypothesis: People reason as if uncertainty is measured by subjective probability. вЂў For most scholars, this is a normative claim. вЂў For some scholars, this is a descriptive claim. Bayesian theory accomplishes two things: 1. Tells us how our existing beliefs should adjust to new information. Tells us how our probabilities should change as we acquire new.

### (PDF) Qualitative Verbal Explanations in Bayesian Belief

The psychology of Bayesian reasoning apps.dtic.mil. Bayesian networks (Pearl, 1988) oп¬Ђer compact and intuitive graphical representations of the uncertain relations among the random variables in a domain and have become the basis of many probabilistic expert systems (Heckerman, Mamdani, & Wellman, 1995b)., to Bayes s Theorem reasoning that you can learn from looking at Bayes Theorem For example An Intuitive and Short Explanation of BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem November 6th, 2007 - ThereГўв‚¬в„ўs a lot being said about Bayes BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem on A Guide to BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem be given as an example of applications of the Bayes Theorem Download PDF Bayes Theorem Examples An Intuitive Guide - вЂ¦.

Where the Intuitive Explanation focused on providing a firm grasp of Bayesian basics, A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation builds, on a Bayesian foundation, theses about human rationality and philosophy of science. The Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning promised that mastery of addition, multiplication, and division would be sufficient background, with no subtraction understanding of the methods as they are introduced through well-motivated and intuitive examples and attractive case studies. The authors do this in such a way that readers with little previous exposure to probability theory and statistics will be able to grasp and appreciate the power of Bayesian networks. While this in itself is already a major achievement, the authors go far beyond this by

An intuitive primer on Bayesian decoding Setup LetвЂ™s say we have a rodent running on a linear track divided into three regions: x 1, x 2, and x 3 ( g. 1). An Intuitive Explanation of Bayes Theorem.pdf - Download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online.

reasoning are a prerequisite for wider acceptance of Bayesian methods in expert systems and decision support systems. A study of human reasoning under uncertainty suggests two different strategies 7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis.

9/10/2014В В· Most psychological research on Bayesian reasoning since the 1970s has used a type of problem that tests a certain kind of statistical reasoning performance. The subject is given statistical facts within a hypothetical scenario. Those facts include a base-rate statistic and one or two diagnostic This document is В©2008 by Eliezer Yudkowsky and free under the Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 License for copying and distribution, вЂ¦

Section 12.2 gives an intuitive explanation of what propositional logic is, and why it is useful. The next section, 12,3, introduces an algebra for logical expressions with Intuitive Logic Revisited: New Data and a Bayesian Mixed Model Meta-Analysis Henrik Singmann 1;, Karl Christoph Klauer , David Kellen1 1 Institut fur Psychologie, Albert-Ludwigs-Universit at Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany E-mail: henrik.singmann@psychologie.uni-freiburg.de Abstract Recent research on syllogistic reasoning suggests that the logical status (valid vs. invalid) of even di cult

The integration ofprior knowledge and new evidence in Bayesian reasoning also gives Bayesian inference a characteristic combination ofstability and flexibility-alearner will be reluctant to give up a strongly-confirmedhypothesis, but even the most entrenched idea can be rejected if The psychology of Bayesian reasoning DavidR.Mandel* Socio-Cognitive Systems Section, Defence Research and Development Canada and Department of Psychology, York вЂ¦

Socio-Cognitive Systems Section, Defence Research and Development Canada and Department of Psychology, York University, Toronto, ON, Canada Most psychological research on Bayesian reasoning since the 1970s has used a type of problem that tests a certain kind of statistical reasoning performance. The Finally, Bayesian reasoning is relevant to some important philosophical claims, such as Hume's position on miracles, design arguments for god, Occam's razor, and the principle that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

understanding of the methods as they are introduced through well-motivated and intuitive examples and attractive case studies. The authors do this in such a way that readers with little previous exposure to probability theory and statistics will be able to grasp and appreciate the power of Bayesian networks. While this in itself is already a major achievement, the authors go far beyond this by Where the Intuitive Explanation focused on providing a firm grasp of Bayesian basics, A Technical Explanation of Technical Explanation builds, on a Bayesian foundation, theses about human rationality and philosophy of science. The Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning promised that mastery of addition, multiplication, and division would be sufficient background, with no subtraction

In An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning I tried to provide visual and physical metaphors for Bayesian probability; for example, evidence is a weight, a pressure upon belief, that slides prior probabilities to posterior probabilities. 9/10/2014В В· Most psychological research on Bayesian reasoning since the 1970s has used a type of problem that tests a certain kind of statistical reasoning performance. The subject is given statistical facts within a hypothetical scenario. Those facts include a base-rate statistic and one or two diagnostic

changes in the likelihood or the prior in a way that accords with our intuitive reasoning. The Bayesian framework is generative, meaning that observed data are assumed to be generated by some underlying process or mechanism responsible for creating the Intuitive Guide PDF. Bayes theorem describes the probability of an event based on other information that might be relevant. Essentially, you are estimating a probability, but then updating that estimate based on other things that you know.This book is designed to give you an intuitive understanding of how to use Bayes Theorem. It starts with the definition of what Bayes Theorem is, but the

Keywords: Explanation, Bayesian belief networks, qualitative probabilistic networks 1 Introduction The purpose of computing is insight, not numbers. Richard Wesley Hamming As the increasing number (Excerpts of) An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning Bayes' Theorem for the curious and bewildered; an excruciatingly gentle introduction. By Eliezer Yudkowsky Your friends and colleagues are talking about something called "Bayes' Theorem" or "Bayes' Rule", or something called Bayesian reasoning.

7/05/2005В В· To justify this assertion, this article will explain how bayesian reasoning is a natural part of clinical decision making, particularly as it pertains to the clinical history and physical examination, and how bayesian approaches are a powerful and intuitive approach to the differential diagnosis. The most popular online tutorial on BayesвЂ™ Theorem, Eliezer YudkowskyвЂ™s вЂњAn Intuitive Explanation of BayesвЂ™ Theorem,вЂќ opens like this: Your friends and colleagues are talking about something called вЂњBayesвЂ™ TheoremвЂќ or вЂњBayesвЂ™ RuleвЂќ, or something called Bayesian reasoning.

### Bayes Mammography Bayesian Inference

Simplicity and Goodness-of-Fit in Explanation The Case of. Finally, Bayesian reasoning is relevant to some important philosophical claims, such as Hume's position on miracles, design arguments for god, Occam's razor, and the principle that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence., Intuitive Logic Revisited: New Data and a Bayesian Mixed Model Meta-Analysis Henrik Singmann 1;, Karl Christoph Klauer , David Kellen1 1 Institut fur Psychologie, Albert-Ludwigs-Universit at Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany E-mail: henrik.singmann@psychologie.uni-freiburg.de Abstract Recent research on syllogistic reasoning suggests that the logical status (valid vs. invalid) of even di cult.

An Intuitive Explanation of Bayes' Theorem Hacker News. causal understanding of a problem leads to increased adoption of Bayesian reasoning, promotes the use of non-Bayesian heuristic strategies, or leads to a mixture of such strategies across individuals., Finally, Bayesian reasoning is relevant to some important philosophical claims, such as Hume's position on miracles, design arguments for god, Occam's razor, and the principle that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence..

### An Intuitive Explanation of Eliezer YudkowskyвЂ™s Intuitive

Intuitive statistics Wikipedia. 10/4/2012 4 The role of data is to re-allocate credibility: В©John K.Kruschke, Oct.2012 Bayesian reasoning in data analysis is intuitive: Possibilities are parameter valuesin a A General, Practicable Deп¬Ѓnition of Perfect Bayesian Equilibrium Joel Watson February 2017 Abstract This paper develops a general deп¬Ѓnition of perfect Bayesian equilibrium (PBE) for.

Yudkowsky's "Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning" and Rovner's "BayesApplet" may both be freely used by any nonprofit organization or educational institution. No royalties or per-page charges are necessary to reproduce this document as course materials, either in printed form or online. 10/4/2012 4 The role of data is to re-allocate credibility: В©John K.Kruschke, Oct.2012 Bayesian reasoning in data analysis is intuitive: Possibilities are parameter valuesin a

a domain-general intuitive theory, and ask whether this knowledge can be learned from co- occurrence of events. We begin by phrasing the causal Bayes nets theory of causality, and a Bayesian networks (Pearl, 1988) oп¬Ђer compact and intuitive graphical representations of the uncertain relations among the random variables in a domain and have become the basis of many probabilistic expert systems (Heckerman, Mamdani, & Wellman, 1995b).

to Bayes s Theorem reasoning that you can learn from looking at Bayes Theorem For example An Intuitive and Short Explanation of BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem November 6th, 2007 - ThereГўв‚¬в„ўs a lot being said about Bayes BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem on A Guide to BayesГўв‚¬в„ў Theorem be given as an example of applications of the Bayes Theorem Download PDF Bayes Theorem Examples An Intuitive Guide - вЂ¦ Bayesian Linear Regression reflects the Bayesian framework: we form an initial estimate and improve our estimate as we gather more data. The Bayesian viewpoint is an intuitive way of looking at the world and Bayesian Inference can be a useful alternative to its frequentist counterpart .

The integration ofprior knowledge and new evidence in Bayesian reasoning also gives Bayesian inference a characteristic combination ofstability and flexibility-alearner will be reluctant to give up a strongly-confirmedhypothesis, but even the most entrenched idea can be rejected if An intuitive primer on Bayesian decoding Setup LetвЂ™s say we have a rodent running on a linear track divided into three regions: x 1, x 2, and x 3 ( g. 1).

Yudkowsky's "Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning" and Rovner's "BayesApplet" may both be freely used by any nonprofit organization or educational institution. No royalties or per-page charges are necessary to reproduce this document as course materials, either in printed form or online. (Excerpts of) An Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning Bayes' Theorem for the curious and bewildered; an excruciatingly gentle introduction. By Eliezer Yudkowsky Your friends and colleagues are talking about something called "Bayes' Theorem" or "Bayes' Rule", or something called Bayesian reasoning.

4/01/2011В В· An Intuitive Explanation of Bayes Theorem 1-4-2011 - Download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online. Coherence, Explanation, and Bayesian Networks David H. Glass Faculty of Informatics, University of Ulster, Newtownabbey, BT37 0QB, UK dh.glass@ulster.ac.uk Abstract. This paper discusses the relevance of coherence to deciding between competing explanations. It provides a basic definition of coherence in probabil-istic terms, which yields a coherence measure and can easily be extended вЂ¦

One important application of Bayesian epistemology has been to the analysis of scientific practice in Bayesian Confirmation Theory. In addition, a major branch of statistics, Bayesian statistics , is based on Bayesian principles. Intuitive statistics, or folk statistics, refers to the cognitive phenomenon where organisms use data to make generalizations and predictions about the world. This can be a small amount of sample data or training instances, which in turn contribute to inductive inferences about either population-level properties, future data, or both.